LWLC Wiki

Search this site

Summary: AI-assisted (Claude) from transcripts

Summary

Expectations

Everyone carries them — about a coming trip, a meeting on the calendar, the rest of an ordinary afternoon. Expectations shape how we receive people and events, and they shape, often without our noticing, how we receive Jesus. Luke 23:6–12 puts that dynamic on full display when the Lord is sent from Pilate to Herod Antipas, the tetrarch of Galilee.

Herod's Expectations

Herod and Pilate were enemies. Pilate had slaughtered some of Herod's Galilean subjects Luke 13:1, and Herod had once gone over Pilate's head to Caesar. Yet when Pilate learned that Jesus fell under Herod's jurisdiction, he sent him over. Herod, for his part, was glad — not because he sought repentance, but because "he was hoping to see him perform some sign" Luke 23:8. He had heard of the miracles, beheaded John, and worried whether this was John raised, or Elijah, or another prophet Luke 9:7–9. He wanted spectacle.

What he received was silence. Jesus, questioned at length, gave him no answer — fulfilling Isaiah's word that he was oppressed and afflicted, "yet he opened not his mouth" Isaiah 53:7. To a ruler this was an insult; to the prophets it was the very mark of the Suffering Servant. Disappointed, Herod mocked him, dressed him in elegant clothing, and sent him back. The temptation that lurks in the Expectations text is plain: when Jesus does not perform on cue, do we, like Herod, dismiss him?

Jesus' Expectations

The mirror turns. For three years Jesus poured his life into the Twelve — calling them by name, teaching, healing in their sight, the spotless Lamb of God present and touchable. And still they argued over which of them was greatest right after he foretold his cross Luke 9:46; they all forsook him and fled Mark 14:50; they dismissed the resurrection report from the women as an idle tale Luke 24:11.

Measure ourselves against the Beatitudes Matthew 5:3–9 and the gap widens. Blessed are the poor in spirit — yet we resist admitting our spiritual poverty. Blessed are those who mourn — yet we can celebrate sin rather than grieve it. Blessed are the meek, the merciful, the pure in heart, the peacemakers — and we know how often we exemplify the opposite. Held to Jesus' expectations, we stand condemned.

The Subversion of Expectation

Composers and authors know a technique called the subversion of expectation: the music or the story turns where you did not think it could go. Scripture works this way at every decisive point. God in the flesh comes to earth — and is laid in a feeding trough because there is no room. The King arrives — and girds himself with a towel to wash filthy feet. The Messiah is crowned — with thorns. He is sealed in a tomb — and the tomb cannot hold him.

The same pattern carries into the means of grace. Plain water, ordinary bread, ordinary wine — and yet, as Luther teaches, when God's Word is joined to the water it becomes a life-giving water, and when Christ says "this is my body… this is my blood," it is exactly what he says it is. Christ is truly present in, with, and under the bread and the wine. What we deserve from a holy God is eternal banishment; the reality given us in Christ is sin paid in full, wrath borne by Jesus, the empty tomb, baptism's claim — "mine" — and life everlasting in the presence of God where there is no more crying or mourning or tears Revelation 21:4.

Resembling the One Who Subverts

If our Lord meets our failed expectations with mercy rather than dismissal, then those who follow him are called to do the same. Someone this week will not live up to what we hoped. A group will let us down out of the blue and leave us low. The Herod-response is mockery and dismissal; the Christ-response is grace, mercy, and service toward the very people who disappointed us. Lived out by God's grace, that resemblance glorifies him — and makes the world, in some small corner, just a little different.

Video citations